5 Best Natural Shaving Creams: Comfortably Smooth in 2024

No one wants an uncomfortable shave, especially if it leaves you with irritated and itchy skin.

Great shaving creams are made of natural ingredients and are free from harmful materials like parabens and phthalates.

Apart from letting your razor glide smoothly, they should moisturize and cleanse your skin, leaving them vibrant, soft, and healthy.

I searched far and wide for the best natural shaving creams that will suit your grooming needs like a nice thick lather and a nick-free, comfortable shave.

Key Takeaways

I researched dozens of brands, Amazon listings, and customer reviews to uncover the best natural shaving creams. I chose my top five picks based on ingredients, consistency, and skin type.

My pick for best overall is the MARLOWE No. 141 Shave Cream, which offers a smooth, silky texture when you lather up and it’s then followed by the budget-friendly Andalou Naturals CannaCell Men Smooth Glide Shave Cream, which is packed with antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals that prevent aging and protect against the sun’s UV rays.

Why it’s great: The MARLOWE No. 141 Shave Cream lathers up nicely, even if you just drop a dollop into a bowl. The silky-smooth texture feels heavenly as you spread it across your beard or head. The light and woody scent of aloe and citrus makes your skincare routine refreshing as you glide the razor across your face.

Apart from giving a close shave, this natural shaving cream has shea butter and coconut oil that help soften your skin. It’s paraben- and phthalate-free so you don’t have to worry about irritation from harmful chemicals. There’s also no dry feeling after you rinse the cream off.

Who is this for? Guys who want a reliably close and smooth shave at a decent price.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: There might be a slight burning sensation if left on your face for too long.

Skin type: Sensitive, Normal | Benefit: For Sensitive Skin | Form: Cream

Why it’s great: A bit on the expensive side, The Art of Shaving’s Cream for Men can effectively soften your hair for a much-needed close shave. It produces a thick and foamy lather that also protects your skin from irritation.

A fingerful of cream is enough to prepare any kind of beard for a smooth shave. You’re treated to a soothing sandalwood scent that lingers for a while, even when you rinse the cream off. Using the Art of Shaving Cream leaves your skin soft every shaving session with a spicy, sexy aroma.

Who is this for? This is one of the best natural shaving creams. It’s perfect for men who want an organic shaving cream that lathers up fully even when using just a fingerful. Using this is like entering into a fancy barbershop.

laws but not deal-breakers: The cream dries off too quickly.

Skin type: Sensitive | Benefit: For protecting skin from irritation | Form: Cream, Gel

Why it’s great: Cultivated from hemp stem cells, the Andalou Naturals CannaCell Men Smooth Glide Shave Cream is packed with antioxidants that protect your skin from premature aging, pollution, and UV exposure.

It contains Vitamin C that supports skin vitality, hemp oil to nourish the skin, and aloe vera for hydration and moisture protection. It easily comes off when you rinse afterward—there’ll be no residual lotions left when you’re done.

Made with 98% nature-derived ingredients and cruelty-free, this $10 natural shaving cream is a bang-for-your-buck grooming product that will keep your sessions comfortable and guilt-free.

Who is this for? Men looking for an affordable, organic shaving cream without shelling out half a day’s pay.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: Customers have noted that it doesn’t lather up as well as other brands.

Skin type: Dry | Benefit: For smooth, shave-ready skin | Form: Cream

Why it’s great: The Pacific Shaving Company Natural Shaving Cream is a plant-derived grooming product that can give you the smoothest shave without chemicals. It’s made from shea butter, menthol, coconut and vegetable oil, sunflower seed oil, and spearmint.

It also comes in a travel-sized 3.4-oz package, so you can take it anywhere in case you need to nip a few hairs on the go. Best used by hand instead of a brush, it produces minimal lather but effectively lubricates and hydrates your skin minus the irritation.

Think of it as sacrificing appearance for functionality. Despite the lack of lather, you can still easily glide your razor with little concern for nicks and cuts.

Who is this for? Guys who are always on the go will appreciate this cream’s travel-friendly bottle.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: Some might not feel comfortable with the lack of lather.

Skin type: Oily, Combination, Sensitive, Dry, Normal | Benefit: For removing dead skin cells, cleansing, and moisturizing skin | Form: Cream

Why it’s great: Crafted from the brand’s castile soap base mixed with organic white grape juice, Dr. Bronner’s Organic Shaving Soap keeps your skin nourished and moisturized after every shave. The organic coconut-olive-hemp oil blend produces a creamy lather that  needs only a dollop to shave the thickest locks of hair.

Once rinsed, you’ll leave with a cleaner, softer, smoother, and more moisturized skin. It has a hint of soapy scent but doesn’t stick to your skin after rinsing. People who are particular about aromas will enjoy using this organic shaving soap.

All the ingredients are grown by fairly paid farmers in Ecuador who employ sustainable harvesting techniques. You’re free to enjoy your shaving sessions and help benefit communities and the planet at the same time.

Who is this for? The ideal choice for people who live a healthier, organic lifestyle.

Flaws but not deal-breakers: This organic shaving cream has a runny, watery consistency.

Skin type: Dry | Benefit: For cleansing and hydrating skin | Form: Powder

Buying Considerations For the Best Natural Shaving Creams

Ingredients

In searching for the best natural shaving creams, it’s paramount to check the ingredients. The products should have no ingredients that can irritate or harm sensitive skin like parabens, phthalates, or alcohol.

You’ll want options that are made from organic, natural, or vegan-friendly extracts. You can also choose aromatic scents, which add a more refreshing shaving session.

Consistency

The right consistency will definitely enhance your experience when you glide your safety razor on your skin. You can go for creams that build into a thick lather for a smoother shave.

There are gel-based or powder ones that may not turn into froth but can effectively cleanse, hydrate, and even protect your skin. Everything depends on your needs and preferences, so choose items that fit you best.

Skin Type

Some organic shaving cream may fit certain skin types more; others apply to all. Your skin’s condition may have specific needs, so consider that when buying grooming products.

If you have dry skin, then kits that have moisturizing and hydrating effects will benefit you more. Guys who have sensitive skin will enjoy options that are full of vitamins and minerals to maintain their health and protect them from harmful elements.

How We Chose

There are a lot of shaving cream brands that use natural ingredients and have great features, but that’s not always best for everyone. The truth is that each shaving cream works differently for certain people.

With this in mind, I read through customer reviews and product descriptions to find the best natural shaving creams that would be best for different types of guys based on these factors:

Purpose: Are they unscented? Do they produce a thick lather or hydrate the skin? I searched for shaving creams that served the right purpose and avoided ones that claimed to work for everyone and every skin type.

Customer Reviews: What do people who previously purchased the product say about the item? Analyzing customer reviews is one effective way to determine a great product when making these selections.

Price: You can avoid wasting money on the most expensive option when the affordable alternative already matches your needs. I balance price and quality when suggesting the best organic shaving cream.

Why Trust Us?

Joe Niehaus is an experienced product reviewer and researcher who has written notable pieces for popular websites like The Adult Man and Travel + Leisure. He’s also covered similar categories like finding the best shaving brushes. He’s strongly familiar with what organic shaving cream men need for their regular grooming sessions.

Joe’s careful approach to finding the best natural shaving creams involves analyzing the ingredients and working with industry experts. His readers get valuable first-hand experience and tailored recommendations as opposed to generic descriptions—allowing them to make informed decisions based on real-life customer testimonials.

Final Verdict 

The best natural shaving creams are made of all-natural ingredients and offer plenty of skin protection and improvement while maintaining a reasonable price.

The MARLOWE No. 141 Shave Cream takes the top overall spot because of its silky smooth lather and ability to prevent skin irritation. More than 918 satisfied customers gave it a 5-star rating on Amazon, so it’s worth a try.